Merge pull request #2431 from KLayout/bugfix/issue-2429

Bugfix: Fixing issue #2429 (PEX error)

src/db/db/dbPLC.cc

@@ -903,10 +903,10 @@ Graph::bbox () const
 }
 
 db::Layout *
-Graph::to_layout (bool decompose_by_id) const
+Graph::to_layout (bool decompose_by_id, double dbu) const
 {
   db::Layout *layout = new db::Layout ();
-  layout->dbu (0.001);
+  layout->dbu (dbu);
 
   auto dbu_trans = db::CplxTrans (layout->dbu ()).inverted ();
 
@@ -950,9 +950,9 @@ Graph::to_layout (bool decompose_by_id) const
 }
 
 void
-Graph::dump (const std::string &path, bool decompose_by_id) const
+Graph::dump (const std::string &path, bool decompose_by_id, double dbu) const
 {
-  std::unique_ptr<db::Layout> ly (to_layout (decompose_by_id));
+  std::unique_ptr<db::Layout> ly (to_layout (decompose_by_id, dbu));
 
   tl::OutputStream stream (path);
 

src/db/db/dbPLC.h

@@ -879,13 +879,13 @@ public:
    *  according to bit 0, 1 and 2 of the ID (useful with the 'mark_polygons'
    *  flat in TriangulateParameters).
    */
-  void dump (const std::string &path, bool decompose_by_id = false) const;
+  void dump (const std::string &path, bool decompose_by_id = false, double dbu = 0.001) const;
 
   /**
    *  @brief Creates a new layout object representing the polygon graph
    *  This method is for testing purposes mainly.
    */
-  db::Layout *to_layout (bool decompose_by_id = false) const;
+  db::Layout *to_layout (bool decompose_by_id = false, double dbu = 0.001) const;
 
 protected:
   Vertex *create_vertex (double x, double y);

src/db/db/dbPLCTriangulation.cc

@@ -42,11 +42,8 @@ static inline bool is_equal (const db::DPoint &a, const db::DPoint &b)
          std::abs (a.y () - b.y ()) < std::max (1.0, (std::abs (a.y ()) + std::abs (b.y ()))) * db::epsilon;
 }
 
-//  distance of point to vertex to be considered "on edge vertex" relative to edge length involved
-const double snap_to_edge_vertex = 1e-5;
-
 //  distance of point to edge center to be considered "on edge center" relative to edge length involved
-double snap_to_edge_center = 1e-3;
+const double snap_to_edge_center = 1e-3;
 
 
 Triangulation::Triangulation (Graph *graph)
@@ -238,70 +235,67 @@ Triangulation::insert_point (db::DCoord x, db::DCoord y, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<
 Vertex *
 Triangulation::insert (Vertex *vertex, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<Polygon> > *new_triangles)
 {
-  std::vector<Polygon *> tris = find_triangle_for_point (*vertex);
+  Polygon *in_triangle = 0;
+  Edge *on_edge = 0;
 
-  //  the new vertex is outside the domain
-  if (tris.empty ()) {
+  if (! find_triangle_for_point (*vertex, in_triangle, on_edge)) {
+
+    //  the new vertex is outside the domain
     tl_assert (! m_is_constrained);
     insert_new_vertex (vertex, new_triangles);
     return vertex;
-  }
-
-  //  check, if the new vertex is on an edge (may be edge between triangles or edge on outside)
-  Edge *on_edge = 0;
-  std::vector<Edge *> on_vertex;
-  for (int i = 0; i < 3; ++i) {
-
-    Edge *e = tris.front ()->edge (i);
-
-    double snap_range = snap_to_edge_vertex * e->length ();
-
-    if (std::abs (e->edge ().distance (*vertex)) < snap_range - db::epsilon) {
-      if (vertex->distance (*e->v1 ()) < snap_range + db::epsilon || vertex->distance (*e->v2 ()) < snap_range + db::epsilon) {
-        on_vertex.push_back (e);
-      } else if (! on_edge) {
-        on_edge = e;
-      }
-    }
 
   }
 
   if (on_edge) {
 
-    split_triangles_on_edge (vertex, on_edge, new_triangles);
+    if (is_equal (*vertex, *on_edge->v1 ())) {
+      return on_edge->v1 ();
+    } else if (is_equal (*vertex, *on_edge->v2 ())) {
+      return on_edge->v2 ();
+    } else {
+      split_triangles_on_edge (vertex, on_edge, new_triangles);
+      return vertex;
+    }
+
+  } else if (in_triangle) {
+
+    split_triangle (in_triangle, vertex, new_triangles);
     return vertex;
 
-  } else if (! on_vertex.empty ()) {
+  } else {
 
-    tl_assert (on_vertex.size () == size_t (2));
-    return on_vertex.front ()->common_vertex (on_vertex [1]);
-
-  } else if (tris.size () == size_t (1)) {
-
-    //  the new vertex is inside one triangle
-    split_triangle (tris.front (), vertex, new_triangles);
-    return vertex;
+    tl_assert (false);
+    return 0;
 
   }
-
-  tl_assert (false);
 }
 
-std::vector<Polygon *>
-Triangulation::find_triangle_for_point (const db::DPoint &point)
+bool Triangulation::find_triangle_for_point (const db::DPoint &point, Polygon *&in_triangle, Edge *&on_edge)
 {
   Edge *edge = find_closest_edge (point);
 
-  std::vector<Polygon *> res;
   if (edge) {
-    for (auto t = edge->begin_polygons (); t != edge->end_polygons (); ++t) {
-      if (t->contains (point) >= 0) {
-        res.push_back (t.operator-> ());
+
+    if (edge->side_of (point) == 0) {
+
+      on_edge = edge;
+      return true;
+
+    } else {
+
+      for (auto t = edge->begin_polygons (); t != edge->end_polygons (); ++t) {
+        if (t->contains (point) >= 0) {
+          in_triangle = t.operator-> ();
+          return true;
+        }
       }
+
     }
+
   }
 
-  return res;
+  return false;
 }
 
 Edge *
@@ -1140,17 +1134,23 @@ static bool is_touching (const db::DEdge &a, const db::DEdge &b)
 std::vector<Edge *>
 Triangulation::ensure_edge_inner (Vertex *from, Vertex *to)
 {
-  auto crossed_edges = search_edges_crossing (from, to);
   std::vector<Edge *> result;
 
+  //  check if there is an edge already
+  Edge *already_there = find_edge_for_points (*from, *to);
+  if (already_there) {
+    result.push_back (already_there);
+    return result;
+  }
+
+  auto crossed_edges = search_edges_crossing (from, to);
+
   db::DEdge dedge (*from , *to);
 
   if (crossed_edges.empty ()) {
 
     //  no crossing edge - there should be a edge already
-    Edge *res = find_edge_for_points (*from, *to);
-    tl_assert (res != 0);
-    result.push_back (res);
+    tl_assert (false);
 
   } else if (crossed_edges.size () == 1 && ! is_touching (dedge, crossed_edges.front ()->edge ())) {
 
@@ -1171,7 +1171,7 @@ Triangulation::ensure_edge_inner (Vertex *from, Vertex *to)
       db::DPoint p = (*e)->intersection_point (dedge);
       double dp = fabs ((p - *from).sq_length () - l_half);
       if (d < 0.0 || dp < d) {
-        dp = d;
+        d = dp;
         split_point = p;
         split_edge = *e;
       }
@@ -1396,6 +1396,9 @@ template DB_PUBLIC void Triangulation::make_contours (const db::DPolygon &, cons
 void
 Triangulation::create_constrained_delaunay (const db::Region &region, const CplxTrans &trans)
 {
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::Polygon (region.bbox ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
 
   for (auto p = region.begin_merged (); ! p.at_end (); ++p) {
@@ -1408,6 +1411,9 @@ Triangulation::create_constrained_delaunay (const db::Region &region, const Cplx
 void
 Triangulation::create_constrained_delaunay (const db::Polygon &p, const CplxTrans &trans)
 {
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::Polygon (p.box ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   make_contours (p, trans, edge_contours);
 
@@ -1417,6 +1423,9 @@ Triangulation::create_constrained_delaunay (const db::Polygon &p, const CplxTran
 void
 Triangulation::create_constrained_delaunay (const db::DPolygon &p, const DCplxTrans &trans)
 {
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::DPolygon (p.box ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   make_contours (p, trans, edge_contours);
 
@@ -1485,6 +1494,9 @@ Triangulation::triangulate (const db::Region &region, const std::vector<db::Poin
 
   clear ();
 
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::Polygon (region.bbox ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   for (auto p = region.begin_merged (); ! p.at_end (); ++p) {
     make_contours (*p, trans, edge_contours);
@@ -1514,6 +1526,9 @@ Triangulation::triangulate (const db::Polygon &poly, const std::vector<db::Point
 
   clear ();
 
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::Polygon (poly.box ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   make_contours (poly, trans, edge_contours);
 
@@ -1539,6 +1554,9 @@ Triangulation::triangulate (const db::Polygon &poly, const std::vector<db::Point
 
   clear ();
 
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::Polygon (poly.box ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   make_contours (poly, trans, edge_contours);
 
@@ -1564,6 +1582,9 @@ Triangulation::triangulate (const db::DPolygon &poly, const std::vector<db::DPoi
 
   clear ();
 
+  std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > box_contours;
+  make_contours (db::DPolygon (poly.box ()), trans, box_contours);
+
   std::vector<std::vector<Vertex *> > edge_contours;
   make_contours (poly, trans, edge_contours);
 

src/db/db/dbPLCTriangulation.h

@@ -335,7 +335,7 @@ private:
   void remove_inside_vertex (Vertex *vertex, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<Polygon> > *new_triangles_out = 0);
   std::vector<Polygon *> fill_concave_corners (const std::vector<Edge *> &edges);
   void fix_triangles (const std::vector<Polygon *> &tris, const std::vector<Edge *> &fixed_edges, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<Polygon> > *new_triangles);
-  std::vector<Polygon *> find_triangle_for_point (const db::DPoint &point);
+  bool find_triangle_for_point (const db::DPoint &point, Polygon *&in_triangle, Edge *&on_edge);
   Edge *find_closest_edge (const db::DPoint &p, Vertex *vstart = 0, bool inside_only = false) const;
   Vertex *insert (Vertex *vertex, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<Polygon> > *new_triangles = 0);
   void split_triangle (Polygon *t, Vertex *vertex, std::list<tl::weak_ptr<Polygon> > *new_triangles_out);

src/db/unit_tests/dbPLCTriangulationTests.cc

@@ -896,8 +896,8 @@ TEST(triangulate_geo)
   }
 
   EXPECT_LT (n_skinny, size_t (20));
-  EXPECT_GT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (29000));
-  EXPECT_LT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (30000));
+  EXPECT_GT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (30000));
+  EXPECT_LT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (30200));
 }
 
 TEST(triangulate_analytic)
@@ -951,8 +951,8 @@ TEST(triangulate_analytic)
     EXPECT_GE (t->b (), param.min_b);
   }
 
-  EXPECT_GT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (1250));
-  EXPECT_LT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (1300));
+  EXPECT_GT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (1300));
+  EXPECT_LT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (1340));
 }
 
 TEST(triangulate_problematic)
@@ -1078,7 +1078,7 @@ TEST(triangulate_issue1996)
   EXPECT_LT (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (132000));
 }
 
-TEST(triangulate_discussion_2883)
+TEST(triangulate_issue_2429)
 {
   db::DPoint contour[] = {
     db::DPoint (-13025.428, -33338.541),
@@ -1114,27 +1114,76 @@ TEST(triangulate_discussion_2883)
   db::DPolygon poly;
   poly.assign_hull (contour + 0, contour + sizeof (contour) / sizeof (contour[0]));
 
-  double dbu = 0.001;
+  double dbu = 1.0;
 
-  db::plc::TriangulationParameters param;
-  param.min_b = 0.3;
+  {
+    db::plc::TriangulationParameters param;
+    param.min_b = 0.3;
+    param.max_area = 0.0;
 
-  db::plc::Graph plc;
-  TestableTriangulation tri (&plc);
-  db::DCplxTrans trans = db::DCplxTrans (dbu) * db::DCplxTrans (db::DTrans (db::DPoint () - poly.box ().center ()));
-  tri.triangulate (trans * poly, param);
+    db::plc::Graph plc;
+    TestableTriangulation tri (&plc);
+    db::DCplxTrans trans = db::DCplxTrans (dbu) * db::DCplxTrans (db::DTrans (db::DPoint () - poly.box ().center ()));
+    tri.triangulate (trans * poly, param);
 
-  EXPECT_EQ (tri.check (false), true);
+    EXPECT_EQ (tri.check (false), true);
 
-  //  for debugging:
-  //  tri.dump ("debug.gds");
+    //  for debugging:
+    //  tri.dump ("debug.gds");
 
-  for (auto t = plc.begin (); t != plc.end (); ++t) {
-    EXPECT_GE (t->b (), param.min_b);
+    for (auto t = plc.begin (); t != plc.end (); ++t) {
+      EXPECT_GE (t->b (), param.min_b);
+    }
+
+    EXPECT_GE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (65));
+    EXPECT_LE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (67));
   }
 
-  EXPECT_GE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (70));
-  EXPECT_LE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (72));
+  {
+    db::plc::TriangulationParameters param;
+    param.min_b = 0.3;
+    param.max_area = 500.0;
+
+    db::plc::Graph plc;
+    TestableTriangulation tri (&plc);
+    db::DCplxTrans trans = db::DCplxTrans (dbu) * db::DCplxTrans (db::DTrans (db::DPoint () - poly.box ().center ()));
+    tri.triangulate (trans * poly, param);
+
+    EXPECT_EQ (tri.check (false), true);
+
+    //  for debugging:
+    //  tri.dump ("debug.gds");
+
+    for (auto t = plc.begin (); t != plc.end (); ++t) {
+      EXPECT_GE (t->b (), param.min_b);
+    }
+
+    EXPECT_GE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (94));
+    EXPECT_LE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (96));
+  }
+
+  {
+    db::plc::TriangulationParameters param;
+    param.min_b = 0.9;
+    param.max_area = 50.0;
+
+    db::plc::Graph plc;
+    TestableTriangulation tri (&plc);
+    db::DCplxTrans trans = db::DCplxTrans (dbu) * db::DCplxTrans (db::DTrans (db::DPoint () - poly.box ().center ()));
+    tri.triangulate (trans * poly, param);
+
+    EXPECT_EQ (tri.check (false), true);
+
+    //  for debugging:
+    //  tri.dump ("debug.gds");
+
+    for (auto t = plc.begin (); t != plc.end (); ++t) {
+      EXPECT_GE (t->b (), param.min_b);
+    }
+
+    EXPECT_GE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (670));
+    EXPECT_LE (plc.num_polygons (), size_t (676));
+  }
 }
 
 TEST(triangulate_with_vertexes)

src/pex/pex/pexRNetExtractor.cc

@@ -339,6 +339,8 @@ private:
     case RExtractorTechConductor::Tesselation:
       {
         pex::TriangulationRExtractor rex (m_dbu);
+        rex.triangulation_parameters ().max_area = mp_cond->triangulation_max_area;
+        rex.triangulation_parameters ().min_b = mp_cond->triangulation_min_b;
         rex.extract (poly, local_vertex_ports, local_polygon_ports, local_network);
       }
       break;

src/pex/unit_tests/pexTriangulationRExtractorTests.cc

@@ -357,7 +357,7 @@ TEST(extraction_meander)
   rex.extract (poly, vertex_ports, polygon_ports, rn);
 
   EXPECT_EQ (rn.to_string (),
-    "R V0 V1 8.61417"          //  what is the "real" value?
+    "R V0 V1 8.60459"          //  what is the "real" value?
   )
 }
 

testdata/ruby/dbPolygonTest.rb

@@ -1062,15 +1062,15 @@ class DBPolygon_TestClass < TestBase
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100);(0,0;1000,100;1100,100);(0,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100;1100,0);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0;275,0);(1000,100;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,325;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;250,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0);(1000,100;1000,325;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
 
     p = RBA::DPolygon::new([ [0, 0], [0, 100], [1000, 100], [1000, 1000], [1100, 1000], [1100, 100], [2200, 100], [2200, 0] ])
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100);(0,0;1000,100;1100,100);(0,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100;1100,0);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0;275,0);(1000,100;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,325;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;250,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0);(1000,100;1000,325;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
 
   end
 

testdata/ruby/dbSimplePolygonTest.rb

@@ -452,15 +452,15 @@ class DBSimplePolygon_TestClass < TestBase
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100);(0,0;1000,100;1100,100);(0,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
     assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100;1100,0);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0;275,0);(1000,100;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,325;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_polygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;250,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0);(1000,100;1000,325;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
 
     p = RBA::DSimplePolygon::new([ [0, 0], [0, 100], [1000, 100], [1000, 1000], [1100, 1000], [1100, 100], [2200, 100], [2200, 0] ])
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100);(0,0;1000,100;1100,100);(0,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, false)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
     assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100;1100,0);(1100,0;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0)")
-    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0;275,0);(1000,100;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,325;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(true, true)), "(0,0;0,100;1000,100;1000,0);(1000,0;1000,100;1100,100;2200,100;2200,0;1100,0);(1000,100;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,100)")
+    assert_equal(sorted_dpolygons(p.hm_decomposition(false, false, 0.0, 0.5)), "(0,0;0,100;250,100;500,100;1000,100;1100,0;825,0;550,0);(1000,100;1000,325;1000,550;1000,775;1000,1000;1100,1000;1100,550;1100,100);(1100,0;1000,100;1100,100);(1100,0;1100,100;1650,100;1925,100;2200,100;2200,0;1650,0;1375,0)")
 
   end
 end